Online Learning Center | BiddingOwl

Guide To Choosing Auction Software for Nonprofits

Written by Adie M. | Sep 9, 2025 2:31:33 PM

Planning a fundraising auction can be exciting, but also incredibly overwhelming. Spreadsheets pile up, paper bid sheets get lost, and someone always has to chase down payments after the event. 

It can feel like you’re managing three full-time jobs at once!

That’s where the right auction software comes in. The right tools make it easier to manage your event, connect with donors, and raise more money for your cause.

So, what does the auction software for nonprofits actually do and how can it help your nonprofit shine? We’ve answered those questions for you, let’s take a look. 

Why Auction Software is Essential for Modern Nonprofit Fundraising

Fundraising has changed a lot in recent years. Supporters expect easy, digital ways to participate. And honestly, paper bid sheets just can’t keep up.

Auction software takes care of the messy details like tracking bids and processing payments, so you don’t have to. 

You can use auction software to support a live event, run a hybrid format, or host a fully online auction. In the online setting, geography is no longer a barrier so more people can join in.

Hybrid and virtual events are also here to stay. More and more people are taking advantage of the flexibility of these event models. Instead of limiting your fundraiser to those who show up in person, software lets you engage a wider community of supporters.

And let’s face it: costs for things like events, programs, or facility rentals pile up fast. Having the right software means you spend less time buried in logistics and more time raising the funds your nonprofit truly needs to keep going.

What to Look for in Nonprofit Auction Software

The good news is that the best platforms share some common traits. Here’s what to look for.

Features Every Platform Should Include

The right auction software should feel like a helping hand, taking the stress out of handling fundraising so you can focus on your mission. 

Here are the main features to look for:

  • Mobile bidding: Supporters are already using their phones to stay connected throughout the day, so why not make it simple for them to bid from anywhere? A good platform lets donors browse items, place bids, and get instant updates, all from the palm of their hand.
  • Item management and cataloging: Uploading auction items shouldn’t feel like a chore. Good software should let you add photos, craft clear descriptions, and organize your catalog with ease. Bonus points if it can pull in data from a spreadsheet and create a professional-looking catalog for you.
  • Secure payment processing: No one wants to chase down checks after an event. With the right software, payments happen conveniently and securely through trusted processors like PayPal or Stripe. That means happier donors and faster cash flow for your cause.
  • Donor registration and bidder management: Every event is an opportunity to grow your community. Good software keeps track of who your donors are, what they’ve given before, and how to stay in touch, so your relationships don’t end when the auction does.
  • Real-time bidding updates: Nothing sparks excitement like a friendly bidding war. Automated “outbid” notifications keep the energy alive and often push final bids higher, all without you having to lift a finger.

Advanced Features That Elevate Your Fundraising

Once you’ve nailed the essentials, these extra features can add excitement, bring in more bids, and make your event feel polished and professional. 

Here’s what to keep an eye out for: 

  • Fund-a-Need and Paddle Raise: Go beyond bidding by giving donors a way to support specific causes directly. Whether it’s funding a program, upgrading facilities, or backing community projects, these tools make live appeals easy and effective.
  • Automated invoicing and receipts: Save your team hours of follow-up. Auction software like BiddingOwl can automatically generate invoices and receipts after checkout. Donors get what they need right away, and you have one less task on your plate.
  • Social sharing tools: Turn your bidders into ambassadors. Some auction solutions let bidders share auction items on social media platforms like Facebook and Instagram, helping you reach new supporters without any extra marketing.

How to Choose the Right Auction Software for Your Nonprofit

Even with all the right features, some auction software works best for specific uses. So, once you’ve narrowed down your options with the above suggestions, keep these points in mind to guide you to your ultimate auction partner. 

1. Match the Software to Your Event Size

A small softball team hosting one auction a year doesn’t need the same tools as a nonprofit running monthly fundraisers. Smaller groups should look for something simple and affordable, while larger organizations will benefit from features like detailed reporting and multi-event management.

2. Consider Your Team’s Tech Comfort Zone

Not every volunteer is a tech wizard, and that’s okay. Prioritize platforms with intuitive, user-friendly dashboards. Easy navigation is better than a long list of complex features you never (or can’t) use.

Training resources can also make a big difference. Some platforms offer robust video libraries, live online training, or step-by-step guides to walk you through the setup process. 

For example, BiddingOwl provides live online training sessions, tutorial videos, and a full Learning Center with how-to guides. 

3. Factor in the Full Cost

Don’t stop at the monthly fee when comparing platforms. Payment processing rates, setup charges, and “extras” can quickly add up. Many providers offer nonprofit discounts, so be sure to ask. Those savings can make a big difference. 

Consider BiddingOwl: there is no monthly fee. Instead, there’s a 5% performance fee on online auctions, which can make budgeting simpler – especially for smaller organizations watching their costs.

4. Plan for Hybrid or Virtual Events

If your fundraiser might include both in-person and online elements, make sure the software supports hybrid formats.

That means guests in the room can bid from their phones while supporters at home can join in online at the same time. Everyone sees the same items, gets the same outbid alerts, and checks out through the same system, no matter where they are.

BiddingOwl is built with this flexibility in mind. You can run a live auction in your venue while opening the same items to online participants, keeping the experience seamless for both groups. It’s an easy way to expand your reach without adding extra layers of work for your team.

5. Ask About Customer Support

Great customer support can make or break your event. Ask about response times, available channels (chat, phone, email), and whether you’ll have a dedicated contact. 

Fast, friendly help matters most on event day because that’s when everything has to run smoothly. If something goes wrong (a bidder can’t log in, payments won’t process, or live updates stall), you need a support team that can jump in right away and fix it.

6. Review Contracts and Cancellation Policies

Avoid getting locked into long-term commitments until you’re sure the platform works for you. Flexible contracts and reasonable cancellation terms protect your organization if things change, like if your event gets canceled or you decide the software isn’t the right fit after a trial run. 

Good terms usually include month-to-month or per-event pricing, the option to cancel with 30 days’ notice, and no penalties or hidden fees if you step away.

7. Allow Time for Setup

Give yourself a cushion of 2–4 weeks to get your auction software up and running. That time goes into things like uploading items, importing donor lists, and personalizing your auction page with your nonprofit’s branding. 

Building in this buffer means you won’t be scrambling at the last minute, and you’ll have space to fix little hiccups before supporters ever see them.

Conclusion: Bringing It All Together

Choosing auction software doesn’t have to feel overwhelming. The key is finding a platform that fits your team’s size, comfort level, and goals. For some nonprofits, that means a simple, budget-friendly option; for others, it’s a more robust system with advanced features.

What matters most is that your software makes life easier, not harder. The right platform will take care of the details and help you connect with more supporters. It frees you up to focus on what fundraising is really about: building relationships and making an impact.

BiddingOwl is here to support your nonprofit in raising more funds with less stress. Get started today and make your efforts even more rewarding.